
The Equation of Grace
Poet Kaveh Akbar’s first novel is a touching, funny, and profound exploration of getting what we need but don’t deserve.
Review by Sarah Clark
Martyr! is one the best books I’ve read in a long time. Many books written in the last fifty years or so, even the good ones, are marred by facile character “development,” by frankly bad writing, or by chronological snobbery, rising to a sense that the author thinks, at least on some level, that the present moment towers above all past moments, and we have nowhere to go but up. Martyr!, on the other hand, is one of those books that transcends its present moment, that touches something of the common humanity that allows us lonely human individuals to see that despite the distances that lie between us, it is possible not to be alone. It’s not a perfect book, but if it were perfect, it would be less fully human than it is. Its excellence is of the kind that matters.
Kaveh Akbar signed my copy for me before I read it, and he also wrote, “May you walk in wonder.” It seemed an odd juxtaposition with the violently yellow cover and the title: Martyr! with an exclamation point. Still, we ought to walk through this world in wonder, even if very few of us succeed at doing so for any sustained period. Annie Dillard writes in Pilgrim at Tinker Creek that if you will but wait quietly, “Not only does something come… but it pours over you like a waterfall, like a tidal wave.” Yet I often find myself too mired in sheer everydayness to find that quiet place to wait, too stuck in Eliot’s “twittering world” to find the darkness. Despite our nearly obverse externals, I have this distractedness in common with the protagonist of Martyr!, Cyrus Shams. We also share a belief in a God who sometimes feels unutterably far away.
Martyr! begins with a spark. We meet Cyrus lying on a mattress on the floor, somewhere between stoned and sober, in a room “that smelled like piss and Febreze.” And there, for a moment, a heartbeat, God reveals himself to Cyrus. And then the moment passes. On the next page, we start with Chapter One, two years later, with the now-sober Cyrus on his way to work, where he plays the part of a dying person (or, as Cyrus likes to think of it, one “of those who will perish”) so medical students can practice giving out bad news. His roommate, the Polish-Egyptian Zee, is concerned this morbid job isn’t good for Cyrus. Zee is probably right.
As the novel unfolds, we learn more about Cyrus and his life. The first few chapters reveal that he is the son of an Iranian immigrant, now deceased, named Ali, and a mother he has never known. Roya Shams was on her way to visit her brother in Dubai when her Iranian commercial flight was inadvertently or accidentally or maybe sort of on purpose shot down by an American aircraft carrier, killing all aboard. “Just shot out of the sky. Like a goose,” Ali reflects in a flashback.
We also learn that Cyrus is a poet, a pretty good one, and that he thinks a lot about dying. His father died while he was a sophomore in college, and he doesn’t know his family back in Iran. He is alone in the world (specifically Indiana), and he carries within himself an eternal, unshakable sense of dread. Where alcohol had occasionally given him the clarity to see “life as everyone else did, as a place that could accommodate you,” he’s now sober but floundering, struggling to feel anything good, or to feel anything at all. He’s angry and suffering and confused. Still, Cyrus holds onto the idea that he wants his life—and his death—to be significant, not just “a rounding error” like his mother’s senseless murder. He decides to write about martyrs: people, as he defines it, who have found a way to make their deaths matter.

People in this story do terrible, inexcusable things that they can never make right. Other people suffer greatly on account on them.
Akbar’s skill as a writer brings Cyrus Shams to life. Weaving between the inside and outside of Cyrus’s head, to other narrators and other times, Akbar makes the world of his characters, their lives, and especially their pain, vividly real. I resonated with Ali’s suffering, as he deals with grief and a baby who barely sleeps, all alone. I raged with Cyrus at a world full of nothing but words that fail to make the pain go away. But I equally felt the moments of hope and humor, as when Cyrus’s AA sponsor Gabe tells him, “There’s no difference to the outside world between a good guy and a bad guy behaving like a good guy. In fact, I think God loves that second guy a little more,” and Cyrus gets it, replying, “Good person drag.”
I don’t want to give any more details here, because I don’t want to spoil this book for you. I want you to read it, to follow along with the reveal of the story as it moves backwards and forwards in time, laying the groundwork for what is to come. Later in the story, we go with Cyrus to meet the Iranian-American artist Orkideh, who is dying of cancer and hosts a performance art exhibit at the Brooklyn Museum so people can talk to her while she’s dying. Much later, Orkideh reflects,
What distinguishes grace from everything else? Grace is unearned. If you’ve moved through the world in such a way as to feel you’ve earned cosmic compensation, then what you’ve earned is something more like justice, like propriety. Not grace. Propriety is correct. Justice is just. There’s an inescapable transactional quality: perform x good, receive y reward. Grace doesn’t work that way. It begins with the reward. Goodness never enters the equation.
Martyr!, fundamentally, is a story about grace. It’s about the real suffering of being human, and about getting what we don’t deserve. People in this story do terrible, inexcusable things that they can never make right. Other people suffer greatly on account on them. It’s about dying and learning to live, and it ends with a miracle. That miracle is forgiveness. A waterfall. A tidal wave. We forget, sometimes, that what we do not deserve is enough to make us whole.
Sarah Clark lives in New Hampshire with her husband and daughter. She is a founding editor of Fare Forward and the current editor-in-chief, and she owns Scale House Print Shop, a letterpress printing studio. She graduated from Dartmouth College in 2011 and received an MAR in Religion & Literature from Yale Divinity School in 2022.
Martyr! was published by Knopf on January 23, 2024. You can purchase a copy from the publisher here.